Sunday, August 10, 2014

Third Reich from the Sun: Nazis, Space Medicine, and The Habitable Zone


Oh yeah… You read that right.
The Nazis.
Space medicine.
And the Circumstellar Habitable Zone.
What do all three of these things have in common?
One brilliant German physiologist’s tarnished reputation. His name was Hubertus Strughold, and he was truly a remarkable man. Today at To Infinity and…In Theory we’re going to talk about this World War II doctor of the Luftwaffe, Operation Paperclip (swear to God, actual name), the beginnings of Space Medicine, and something else.
Oh yeah.
The Habitable Zone.
The Habitable Zone is where we live, Earth. We’re just the right distance from our sun to meet all the requirements to sustain life. But if extremophiles have taught us anything in recent years it’s that the requirements for life may be a little more bendable then we initially led ourselves to believe.
But the Habitable Zone isn’t just important because of Earth, which would be narcissistic to say at best. Turns out, there are billions of planets out there that may meet the requirements to sustain life of some kind. Even rogue planets may experience enough tidal heating to maintain an atmospheric pressure suitable. Our entire way of thinking may have to shift in the search for life..
But before we get too far ahead of ourselves, let’s strap on our combat boots and climb down into the trenches of WWII with Hubertus Strughold.

The Führer of Space Medicine


Here at To Infinity and…In Theory we like to laugh, however…if Monty Python taught us anything it’s that Nazis just aren’t that funny.


So, being that Nazis aren’t funny, you’re probably wondering why I’m making jokes about Dr. Strughold. Well, let me clarify this for you then. I’m making jokes because…drum roll please…
Yep, you guessed it. Hubertus Strughold wasn’t a Nazi.
He was a high ranking medical officer for the Luftwaffe however, which was the German Infantry. Basically, he just worked for the Army…but I can totally see how you’d get those two mixed up… (Kidding…sarcasm…actually can’t believe people get those mixed up…). Several of his assistants and pupils had gone on to work for the Nazi regime however, and before the start of the war Strughold had correspondence with Joseph Goebbels, a high ranking SS officer.
But saying because he knew one psychopath would be akin to saying that because you went to high school with Charles Manson you’re going to grow up to be part of his celebrity killing cult.
Needless to say a brilliant man’s reputation has been tarnished, and brilliant he was indeed. His research during World War II propelled modern aeronautics medicine ahead by decades. I won’t go into the details of the people performing the experimentation processes, but they studied oxygen deprivation and hypothermia amongst other things.
At the end of the war Hubertus found himself on the losing side in an appalling war. I firmly believe he had nothing to do with the Nazi war machine or the abhorrent nature of the Nazis’ atrocities, but that is just one man’s humbly earnest opinion. Needless to say however he had a unique skill set, and Uncle Sam wasn’t one to overlook talent. Hubertus Strughold found himself amongst 1,500 or so odd German doctors, scientists, engineers, and technicians that were immigrated to the United States to work on various projects through a program titled “Operation Paperclip”.


If you’ve seen the Shamwow infomercial you know, “The Germans build good stuff!” Despite the fact the endorser on the advertisement strikes me as a strange fellow and slightly daft he makes a good point. The Germans are well known for building products that are…well, good. They make them to last, and keep great records. Even as a doctor Hubertus was no slouch at sciences in general, which made him an invaluable asset. Good thing they snagged him up in the draft too, because he went on to achieve some truly great things.
He was the first to figure out what the effects of space would be on a human being by overseeing the construction of the Space Cabin Simulator and supervising the testing. He also designed the pressure suit and life support systems used onboard the Apollo missions, without Strughold, we’d have never beat the Russian’s to the moon!
Strughold was investigated extensively by the Department of Justice, and since he was found clean every time, was allowed to continue his work with NASA and the United States government. Hubertus was awarded dual citizenship in the late 50’s and an award was established in his name in 1962. What was the award for you ask? Space medicine. He is known as the Father of Space Medicine after all.
Anyone who advanced the field of space medicine significantly was given the Hubertus Strughold award. It was presented by the Aerospace Medical Association. Every year since 1963 the award has been presented, and a prestigious one it is, but in 2013, due to his tepid past, the Hubertus Strughold award was suspended. It still has not been confirmed as to whether or not it will be brought back. Personally, I hope it will. It isn’t fair to ruin someone’s reputation with slander


. But that didn’t stop him from making major contributions to our space programs and to the medical field in general. I have no need to discuss what happens to your body when it’s exposed to space; from oxygen deprivation to genetic mutations the publication IFLScience.com has a wonderfully written article all about it. You can read that here. In short, they wouldn’t know all that if it wasn’t for Hubertus…and Nazis unfortunately…but not a Nazi Hubertus!
Make sense?
Heaven to Betsy I hope so.
Anyway, it wasn’t just space medicine and alleged war crimes that Hubertus showed a propensity for. He was also, (like almost every scientist who ever existed before him) a bit of a philosopher. He wrote a treatise on physiology in space titled The Green and the Red Planet: A Physiological Study of the Possibility of Life on Mars and in it used the words “ecosphere” and referenced various “zones” in which life could possibly propagate in relation to distance from a star.
While his arguments weren’t exactly grounded in Astrobiological Science, he raised some good points. Which is why shortly after he wrote it in 1953, an American Astronomer took strong interest in it, because unlike Hubertus, he could apply the missing puzzle pieces of the Science that Hubertus had overlooked.
He called it “Liquid Water Belt theory”, and that’s what we’re going to talk about next.

“You Are ‘Here’”


In 1953, Harlow Shapley took Strughold’s theory a step further by making it plausible. He proposed what was then called “Liquid Belt Theory”. In his theory he surmises that given what we knew about the sun, and what we knew about life on Earth and it’s necessity for water, that only planets within a certain “range” of their star would be able to support liquid water at its surface. Therefore, only these planets would be able to sustain life. Sounds like wild conjecture right?
Except for the fact that Shapley was already well beyond qualified to answer these questions. How was he qualified you ask? Well in 1920 he was able to correctly postulate our position in the Milky Way Galaxy and our sun’s relation to it. Long before the technology even existed to correctly just “guess” that kind of thing. The man was a genius.
What was exceptional about him though is that had one known Shapley in his youth, they never would have guessed his massive intellect. He had dropped out of school in the 5th grade, and later, when he applied to a high school, he and his brothers were denied as being “unprepared”. Instead they attended a parochial school, received a diploma, and by 1910, when Harlow was only twenty-five, he received his B.A. with high honors in mathematics and physics.
Not bad for a grade school dropout, eh? A year later he received his Masters and was recommended for the prestigious fellowship offered by Princeton for his remarkable achievements. During his fellowship he disproved the age old theory of Cepheid stars being binaries. It would not be the last time Cepheid’s would be studied and revised however, but his contributions to it were the most tremendous since 1784, when Edward Pigott first proposed it.
So why were the ecosphere and the liquid belt theory so important? Because they became the key components of our next subject. The Circumstellar Habitable Zone.

Goldilocks and the Three Suns


Ecosphere, Biosphere, Hydrosphere, call it whatever you want, but at the end of the day, it’s the golden area of opportunity for life to exist called the Habitable Zone. Colloquially called “The Goldilocks Zone” by some researchers, this area of hospitality in the fundamentally harsh regions of space has been tossed and turned by scientists for decades.
Certain stars burn at certain temperatures. Red dwarf stars tend to be cooler than our medium sized yellow one. Blue stars are thought to burn the hottest. Then you get into Orange, White, and Brown dwarfs, and blah, blah, blah. There’s a dozen or so odd star types, but for our purposes, we’re going to talk about suns that are actually life sustainable.
As you can see from the picture above the areas that are red around each star are the hottest and are deemed inhospitable for life to exist. But if extremophiles here on Earth have taught us anything it’s that life can exist in the most unforgiving environments. (Remember our four part spotlight on Extremophiles? Catch up here! Part One, Part Two, Part Three, Part Four)
So while these zones may not be able to sustain human life as we know it, it could certainly maintain Methanotrophic bacteria, such as the ones that thrive at the bottom of the Marianas trench, or maybe some of the Cryophiles that survive in the depths of Lake Vostok beneath Antarctica. Our understanding of “life as we know it” has shifted drastically in the last decade.
But even cooler still are the planets that can support our kind of life. Humans. Those are the ones that scientists are most interested in. We should all be interested in them too, because we’re quickly destroying our current one, and we may be long overdue already for a reset button.
So where are some of these planets capable of supporting life of some kind? Let’s go all Guardians of the Galaxy…




…and do a little exoplanetary exploration of our own. Also, just as a quick disclaimer, the photos in the accompanying sections of the exoplanets are just artists’ representations (like that amazing concept art above!) and not photographs, still, enjoy!

HD 85512 b


HD 85512 b finds itself nested in the Vela constellation about 36 light-years from our planet. It’s a super-Earth, being that its mass is almost four times bigger than our own. Through the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher (HARPS) program in Switzerland, HD 85512 b was discovered to be flying within the habitable zone and this one could potentially contain liquid water at its surface.
But this one isn’t the only potential candidate for life support abilities. HD 85512 b so far is thought to be one of best, but so isn’t the next one on our list.

Gliese 581 d



Unlike HD 85512 (The Sun of the planet we just talked about) which is an Orange Dwarf, Gliese 581 d orbits a Red Dwarf. According to scientists it would have a dark and murky atmosphere with twice the gravity of Earth. Initially thought to have been tidally locked, this giant with seven times the mass of our planet, has been rethought extensively. Now it’s believed that Gliese 581 d has a dense Co2 atmosphere, meaning it could trap heat well and maintain liquid water on the surface.
The drinkability of that water is questionable and the distance is over twenty light-years from us making this a far off candidate for the distant future. But what about the next one on our list?

Gliese 581 g (or is it??)



Nothing will bring you to the verge of an existential quandary faster than people questioning your existence, (or your status…I miss Pluto…), but that’s exactly what’s happening to 581 g in the Gliese 581 orbit. He orbits the habitable zone, has the potential to harbor liquid water at its surface, maybe even be a better candidate than his brother, but there’s one problem…
They don’t even know if he exists…
Poor Gliese 581 g. Unlike him, we’re certain of the next one, discovered as a part of the Kepler program.

Kepler 186 f



If you thought that HD and Gliese were a long distance off, you were sadly mistaken. Those systems are right around the corner in comparison to the 490 light-years between us and Kepler 186 f. Recently discovered this year back in April, it is only a mere 10% larger than Earth and is the closest planet to Earth in size ever found in a habitable zone.
This is a huge deal. Not only does that mean Kepler 186 f can sustain life as we know it scientists are saying that life could even thrive on its surface. Its system is set up a lot like ours as well, with multiple planets too far away from or too close to their star to sustain life. Unfortunately, its great distance means tremendous strides will have to be made in telescoping technology in order for us to get a close up glimpse of its surface.

Kepler 22 b



But if you thought Kepler 186 was a ways out there, Kepler 22 b is here to tell you that’s just a skip across the pond. At a whopping 600 light-years from us, this Earth 2.0 planet discovered in 2010 was initially thought to be the end-all for the search. With an estimated surface temperature of 72 degree F, Kepler 22 b is more than capable of sustaining liquid water. However, given its distance, that’s probably all we’re really going to know about him for a while.

HD 40307 g



Located a measly 44 light-years away, this Super-Duper mega-sized Earth could hold seven of our little blue balls inside of it. With a length of year slightly half that of ours and a distance of 40 million miles closer to its star, HD 40307 g finds himself right smack in the habitable zone.
Because of its relative closeness to us, next generation telescopes are thought to be able to peer at its surface. Perhaps within a decade we may actually be able to catch a glimpse of life on another planet.

Tau Ceti e



The last one on our list today is the unconfirmed planet Tau Ceti e. The strangest thing about this planet is the fact that it’s unconfirmed when it’s the closest one on our list at only 11 light-years from our sun. Should the confirmation come about however this could prove gigantic to the scientific community, because not only would the surface of the planet be close enough to take snapshots of in a few years, but being in our own “cosmic backyard” could mean Tau Ceti would become the target of future interstellar missions.
Take that Orson Scott Card. No more 3 millennium long trips.
All jokes aside every planet on this list, and many, many more just like them, could prove once and for all that we’re not alone out there in the galaxy. Now the real question is…
Do they even want to meet us?

-       Ryan Sanders



Thanks for reading! As always if you would like to know more feel free to follow any of the links below! Share this around on Twitter, Facebook, Reddit or wherever else Social Media takes you, and be sure to head over to Facebook and give the To Infinity and In Theory page a big thumbs up! Happy Learning everyone!

-       Wiki on Cepheid Stars
-       Wiki on HD 85512 b







No comments:

Post a Comment